The ethics of capital punishment essay 1225 words bartleby. May 29, 2014 capital punishment provides the state the means to apply the appropriate punishment to the crime deut. The ethics of capital punishment matthew kramer oxford. However, the variations appear when it involves what sensibly punishment ought to be applied, predominantly for major crimes like murder.
The book is a frank plea in favor of capital punishment. Relating this to capital punishment or death penalty, it may be said that as according to kants theory, a crime that is proven to be driven by desires and done without rationalization is immoral and therefore may be considered as deserving of capital punishment. Applied ethics focuses the central concepts of traditional morality rights, justice, the good, virtue, and the fundamental value of human life on a number of pressing contemporary problems, including abortion, euthanasia, animals, capital punishment, and war. A prisoner who has been sentenced to death and is awaiting. Capital punishment deters crime by causing wouldbe murderers to fear arrest and conviction and by preventing convicted murderers from killing again. Position statement death penalty information center. Determining the morality of capital punishment philosophy. The term death penalty is sometimes used interchangeably with capital punishment, though imposition of the penalty is not always followed by execution. Even among those professing christian faith, there is widespread opposition to the death penalty. Determining the morality of capital punishment philosophy essay.
Its institution predates israels birth as a nation and moses divinely inspired directions for the nations governance, eliminating the. Kantian and utilitarian ethics on capital punishment it is an indisputable fact that most societies in the world agrees that if a person violates the laws, heshe should be penalized. Crimes that can result in a death penalty are known as capital crimes or capital offences. Capital punishment is in some countries most notably the usa under strong debate. Capital punishment and nurses participation in capital punishment. Ethics of capital punishment mayo clinic proceedings. A philosophical investigation of evil and its consequences. The claim that capital punishment is justified as a means of prevention is defended on some or all of the following grounds among possible others. The question as to whether or not it is morally acceptable for the state to execute people, and if so under what circumstances, has been debated for centuries. Kantian and utilitarian ethics on capital punishment. In recent years, violent crime in new york has dropped dramati. Then, in 1972 came a landmark decision in furman v. By a 54 margin the supreme court ruled that the death laws of georgia and texas violated the eighth amendment.
The term death penalty is sometimes used interchangeably with capital punishment, though imposition of the penalty is not always followed by. Lesson 7 capital punishment 2 2 in the united states some 5,707 people were legally executed for capital crimes in the u. Capital punishment, execution of an offender sentenced to death after conviction by a court of law of a criminal offense. Dialoguesontheethicsofcapitalpunishment download dialoguesontheethicsofcapitalpunishment ebook pdf or read online books in pdf, epub, and mobi format. Click download or read online button to dialoguesontheethicsofcapitalpunishment book pdf for free now. The american psychological association 2001 calls upon each jurisdiction in the u. The fi rst is that of the justifi cation of punishment in general, the second is that of the place of death within his or her overall theory of punishment edmundson 2002, 40. A sentence of death may be carried out by one of five lawful means. An inquiry into the ethics of capital punishment syracuse. Capital punishment is defined as execution as a punishment for a person convicted of committing a crime. Capital punishment continues to be used in the united states despite controversy over its merits and over its effectiveness as a deterrent to serious crime. Pursuing both a project of critical debunking and a project of partial vindication.
The ethics of capital punishment ethics is the study of standards of right and wrong. Capital punishment provides the state the means to apply the appropriate punishment to the crime deut. Capital punishment legal definition of capital punishment. The argument that capital punishment deters crime is hard to prove, but would be an argument in favor for utilitarianism, but just as the categorical imperative.
Among the more important books in criminal justice ethics it is customary to give the arguments both for and against capital punishment, but the full range of pro. In the ethics of capital punishment, matthew kramer takes a fresh look at the philosophical arguments on which the legitimacy of the death penalty stands or falls, and he develops a novel justification of that penalty for a limited range of cases. The state of capital punishment national conference of. Kerby anderson provides a biblical worldview perspective on capital punishment. This paper examines the death penalty question from the perspective of the new ethical theory, the principle. The argument that capital punishment is a deterrence to crime has yet to be satisfactorily proven and in any case the use of human beings as means to a social end is ethically questionable kant, especially when some of those executed will, in fact, be innocent. I believe that the position on death penalty is made by each individuals ethical belief and moral therefore the one who decides on sentence should not have the right to decide in place of the offender national public radio. It is the judicial execution of criminals judged guilty of capital offenses by the state, or in other words, the death penalty. The ethics of capital punishment christian research institute. Capital punishment has many different ethical issues involved in it and paper masters can custom write a research paper on any of the sociological arguments that favor capital punishment. The sections which follow attempt to present the most salient aspects of the most important dimensions of the issue. Pataki 103 the death penalty is a necessary tool for fighting and reducing crime. I hope to demonstrate this by examining how the ethics of care might deal with the topic of punishment. He explores the biblical teaching to help us understand how to consider this controversial topic apply christian love and biblical principles.
In the case of this book, the title and subtitle give, for once, an accurate idea of the contents. Ethics paper assign capital punishment phil 110p odu. Countries employing capital punishment classifies death penalty depending on the virtue ethics present in the specific country. Apr 17, 2009 the ethics of capital punishment synopsis. Is capital punishment ethical capital punishment, death penalty or execution is punishment by death. That a heinous wrong has been committed by the agent to be pun.
The ethics of capital punishment essay 1125 words bartleby. The ethics of capital punishment seeking a standard contrary to modern practice in most jurisdictions, punishment for a crime and restitution for the victim are interrelated concepts. The ethics of capital punishment by fisanick, nick. Though much of this book is devoted to impugning all the standard rationales for capital punishment, the chief purpose of the volume is to advance an alternative justification for such punishment in a very limited range of cases. The case against capital punishment is often made on the basis that society has a moral obligation to protect human life, not take it. Capital punishment and nurses participation in capital.
Capital punishment undermines human dignity which is fundamental to every human being. Capital punishment, also known as the death penalty, is a governmentsanctioned practice whereby a person is put to death by the state as a punishment for a crime. The history of capital punishment in the united states began as the europeans colonized the new world. For example, some countries reserved death penalty for murder and treason while other countries direct death penalty for sexual crimes rape, human and drug trafficking.
However, the variations appear when it involves what sensibly punishment ought. Ethics govern a persons behavior, and when a person is planning on committing a crime, they should already know that their actions will be in violation of the policies and laws that govern the state or country that they plan on. Capital punishment and ethics capital punishment and ethics the use of capital punishment has been a permanent fixture in society since the earliest civilizations and continues to be used as a form of punishment in countries today. The sentence ordering that someone be punished in such a manner is referred to as a death sentence, whereas the act of carrying out such a sentence is known as an execution. Historically, the church has affirmed the right of the civil magistrate in matters of capital justice. Capital punishment internet encyclopedia of philosophy. This form of punishment is usually perceived in the united states as being reserved for crimes such as aggravated murder, felony murder, and contract killing, but in reality the application of capital punishment varies widely. Given the value we place on life and our obligation to. These concerns have prompted changes to capital punishment policy and process and even, on occasion, been sufficient for states to abandon the policy altogether.
The question as to whether or not it is morally acceptable for the state to execute people, and if so under what circumstances, has been debated for. While the volume contributes to many areas of normative ethics, it contributes above all to the philosophy of criminal law with a fresh rationale for the use of the death penalty and with probing assessments of all the major theories of punishment that have been broached by jurists and philosophers for centuries. The ethics of capital punishment christian research. The taking of human life is permissible only if it is a necessary condition to achieving the greatest balance of good over evil for everyone involved. An ethical analysis against capital punishment introduction this paper compares and contrasts the two different ethical perspectives for and against capital punishment. Capital punishment is a very sensitive subject because it touches on many important topics such as justice, costs, humaneness and religion. Capital punishment, or the death penalty, is an institutionalized practice designed to result in deliberately executing persons in response to actual or supposed misconduct and following an authorized, rulegoverned process to conclude that the person is responsible for violating norms that warrant execution. I defend a particular answer to this question, one that invokes an undertheorized conception.
Capital punishment does not yield to simplistic analysis at any levelbiblical, historical, ethical, or practical. The response to an immoral but accepted practice represents an ethical choice. Introduction this paper is the tangible result of an action taken by the baptist general convention of texas in the form of a motion requesting that the christian life commission study and report on the issue of capital punishment. Pdf kantian and utilitarian ethics on capital punishment. The ethics of capital punishment a philosophical investigation of evil and its consequences matthew kramer. Presents accessible critiques of the standard arguments advanced for the death penalty, making valuable introductory reading for students studying the topic. It has been used for various crimes ranging from the desertion of soldiers during wartime to the more heinous. The argument that capital punishment deters crime is hard to prove, but would be an argument in favor for utilitarianism, but just as the categorical imperative fails logically, the execution of the innocent can be justified in. In the case of premeditated murder, compensation is not available as an alternative. The ethical problems involved include the general moral issues of punishment with.
Capital punishment is irreversible and so requires a degree and kind of justification not necessary for nonlethal punishment. British influence is considered to be the foundation of capital punishment in the u. Any analysis of the ethics of capital punishment thus need to echo the supreme courts recognition of the possibility that something that has become accepted in society may nonetheless be immoral. Fortunately, beliefs are not only mental entities, they also influence our behavior. The old testament also teaches that god instituted capital punishment in the jewish law code. Capital punishment reduces crime in some aspects, but it also is taking the life away from the criminal. Capital punishment, ethics, and public opinion posted by nicole smith, dec 15, 2011 politics comments closed print ethical questions are at the forefront of the debate about the permissibility of capital punishment as both a way of deterring crime and making criminals pay for their violent acts against individuals and society. Abolition of the death penalty has boasted, it is thus all the more important to ponder the ethics of capital punishment, since many of the attorneys representing. This ethical principle also applies to efforts by social workers to enhance clients capacity and opportunity for change. So if you want to know what i believe to be true or good, observe my.
Though edmundsons comment accurately summarizes the ways in which the standard rationales for capi. In fact, the principle of capital punishment even precedes the old testament law code. The scope and depth of the paper is commensurate with the complexity of the issue. The purely ethical argument for capital punishment is discussed by many research papers on the death penalty. The death penalty is ethical since it is the only form of retribution when a person commits a heinous crime. God instituted capital punishment as a legitimate punitive option for every state. The sentence that someone be punished in this manner is a death sentence. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. Contemporary culture, in contrast, is permeated with arguments against capital punishment. Introduction to philosophy phil 110p academic year. Increasingly, capital punishment legislation being considered in state legislatures across the nation is focused on concerns over cost, viable methods of execution, intellectual disability, and lengthy trial and appellate procedures. Pursuing both a project of critical debunking and a project of partial vindication, the book presents a rationale for the death penalty that is freestanding rather.
1148 1524 657 1514 1319 1395 638 546 132 156 1228 1401 689 138 1185 749 512 450 704 430 993 117 889 320 811 1233 606 556 497 1233 979 482